Let's start with the obvious: Siddhant Chaturvedi is doing career-best work here. He's got the kind of screen presence that makes you believe a room full of people would follow this man into the unknown. There's a scene where he watches his own footage flicker on a screen and you can practically see the gears turning in his head - that silent, hungry curiosity of someone who knows the medium is about to change and wants to be the one changing it. Chaturvedi plays the ambition without the arrogance, and it's a tricky balance that he nails.
Tamannaah Bhatia, stepping into the shoes of Jayashree, brings warmth and grounding to a film that could otherwise drown in its own reverence. Their scenes together have a lived-in texture that keeps the human cost of genius from getting lost in the spectacle of it all.
Director Abhijeet Deshpande clearly reveres his subject, and that reverence is both the film's engine and its occasional anchor. When he's staging the messy, chaotic energy of a film set - the shouting, the scrambling, the last-minute saves - the movie crackles. But there are stretches where the screenplay gets so caught up in hitting the historical beats that it forgets to let us just sit with the man. We get the milestones. Sometimes we want the quiet moments in between.
The genre tag says Drama, and that's accurate, but this is drama of the "greatest-hits biopic" variety. It's handsomely mounted, with production design that convincingly evokes each era without feeling like a museum exhibit. The film's real magic trick is making the technical evolution of cinema feel like an emotional journey - the first sound, the first color, each treated like a character's personal victory rather than a footnote.
What holds it back from greatness is the familiar biopic trap: it wants to cover everything, so it commits fully to nothing. A whole chapter of Shantaram's life might get three scenes; another might get one. The result is a film that's consistently engaging but rarely immersive for long stretches. And look, the rating situation on this one is currently a goose egg over on TMDb - 0 out of 10 - but that's clearly just the opening-day vacuum before audiences have had a chance to weigh in. Don't read anything into that number; it's not a verdict, it's a blank canvas.