Let's start with the good news: Ariana Grande is a genuine spark here. Casting the pop superstar as a former hostage negotiator is the kind of bonkers swing that could have backfired spectacularly, but she brings a crisp, unbothered confidence that plays beautifully against Stiller's anxious-dad shtick. Watching her disarm De Niro's Jack with calm, measured competence is the movie's most enjoyable running gag.
De Niro, meanwhile, seems to be having actual fun - a rarity in his late-career comedy output. The gag of Jack preferring his grandson's fiancée to his own son-in-law is a smart inversion, and the birthday-party buildup gives the third act some needed propulsion. Director John Hamburg knows his way around this sandbox, and the film moves briskly enough across its 105 minutes.
But here's where things get rocky. Greg Focker, once the frazzled underdog we rooted for, has been reduced to a reactive bundle of tics. Stiller can do this in his sleep - and frequently appears to. The script keeps handing him panic attacks and passive-aggressive jabs where it once gave him actual jokes. Worse, Teri Polo's Pam is barely a presence, and Feldstein's Samantha feels like an afterthought. Meanwhile, Owen Wilson's Kevin, who used to be a scene-stealing gremlin of chaos, gets wheeled out for a handful of wistful nonsense and shuffled off again. You can practically hear the screenwriters flipping through the franchise's greatest-hits binder.
And the jokes? The comedy here is soft, safe, and oddly toothless. Where the original mined discomfort from genuine cultural and class friction, Focker-in-Law settles for sitcom setups and easy payoffs. A subplot about birthday-party seating arrangements is exactly as exciting as it sounds. The central tension - will Greg win back Jack's trust? - resolves with a shrug rather than a crescendo.
Tonally, it wobbles, too. It's not the raucous farce the premise demands, nor is it a tender generational passing-of-the-torch story. It's stuck in a mushy middle, hugging its own legacy so tightly it forgets to generate laughs. That 4/10 rating from TMDb audiences feels harsh in isolation, but honestly? It tracks. This is a legacy sequel that remembers the choreography while forgetting the punchlines.