Twenty years is a long time to hold a torch for anything, let alone a close encounter with something that probably wasn't even human. But that's exactly the predicament Petey finds himself in when Allen opens, and honestly, who among us hasn't refused to move on from something that fundamentally rearranged our brain chemistry?

The new sci-fi adventure comedy from director Daley Pearson hit theaters on November 12, and it's operating on a premise that feels like it was pulled from the stranger corners of a therapy session: what happens when the alien you met two decades ago - the one you never got over - suddenly comes back, and the reason for the return is way more complicated than you'd expect?

T.J. Power leads the charge as Petey, the grown man still stuck on that night twenty years ago, while Edward A O'Sullivan steps in as Young Petey for the flashback material that presumably sets all this in motion. Charlotte Nicdao stars as Carly, with Caitlin Niemotko playing Young Carly, which suggests their history stretches back to that same pivotal encounter. Rounding out the ensemble are Josh Helman as Jaden, Emily Barclay as Sarah, Benedict Hardie as Rory, and Elijah Tamati as Cameron - a cast stacked with the kind of character-actor energy that usually signals a movie having fun with its own premise.

Pearson, making the jump to features, has built a career on high-concept comedy with a genuinely weird streak, and Allen looks like a natural extension of that sensibility. The premise alone is doing a lot of heavy lifting: a middle-aged man whose defining life event happened at whatever age he was twenty years prior, and who has apparently spent every day since nursing that memory like a houseplant. His old friend returns - and the reason why is "complicated and unexpected." That's the kind of logline that either falls apart immediately or swings for something genuinely surprising. Given the tonal stew of science fiction, adventure, and comedy, the smart money says this one is aiming for the latter.

And there's something unexpectedly poignant buried in that setup. Most alien-encounter movies end with the human waving goodbye and walking off into a sunset, lessons learned, character arc complete. Allen is more interested in the people who don't get to walk off. The ones who head home and spend the next two decades waiting for the phone to ring. There's a real melancholy in that idea - the friend who peaked at the most inexplicable moment of their life and never found anything that measured up since - and it's the sort of emotional premise that a comedy can mine for surprising depth as long as it doesn't get too precious about it.

The film landed with a TMDb rating sitting at 6.782 out of 10, which tracks for a movie with a specific sensibility engineered to connect with a specific audience. It's also clocking in at a tight 107 minutes, and honestly, bless any modern genre picture that respects the audience's time enough to get in and out without a three-hour victory lap. Comedies especially live and die by their rhythm, and a runtime north of two hours is usually the first sign that something lost the thread in the edit bay.

What's most interesting about Allen, though, is the question at its center: after twenty years of holding on, what does it actually mean when the thing you've been waiting for finally comes back? Is it closure, or is it just a second chance to make the same mess all over again? Pearson and company seem less interested in the spectacle of the reunion than in the emotional wreckage of a man who built his entire identity around a single night he probably couldn't even explain to his therapist without getting laughed out of the room. Petey is, in his own small way, every person who never quite left their hometown, or never quite forgot their first love, or is still chasing the feeling of one perfect summer. The alien is almost beside the point.

Hollywood has been trying to crack the "sci-fi comedy with a heart" formula for decades, with results ranging from instant classics to cautionary tales, and Allen is clearly throwing its hat in that ring with a killer cast and a premise that refuses to go where you'd expect. Whether audiences click with Petey's twenty-year hangover remains to be seen - but the setup alone is enough to make this one worth a look for anyone who's ever wondered what happens after the credits roll on a first contact. Turns out sometimes the answer is: a lot of unresolved feelings, and one very unexpected houseguest.